Randall K. Spencer, Partner


Arguing cases since his second year of law school

Randall K. Spencer, one of our criminal defense attorneys in Utah County,  has been litigating cases since he completed his second year of law school in 1993. It was then, under the third-year practice rule, that he won his first criminal jury trial.


Randall subsequently worked at the Utah County Public Defender Association, representing indigent people accused of crimes ranging from speeding tickets to homicide. His defense of the First Amendment in one case led to a feature story on Court TV.


Focusing on criminal defense, personal injury, civil litigation and medical malpractice

In the years since he began private practice in 1999, Randall has expanded his practice to include personal injury cases, such as auto accident claims, and civil litigation dealing with real estate, contracts and major business disputes. As a criminal defense attorney in Utah County he handles a variety of cases. He has recovered millions of dollars for clients who have been wrongfully injured as a result of the negligent actions of others.  He continues to handle criminal defense, and despite public criticism, vigorously defended Martin MacNeill, a doctor and lawyer accused of murdering his wife. While the verdict was not the hoped-for result, the case remains under appeal based on evidence Randall uncovered after the trial demonstrating that critical witnesses lied during their testimony. When Randall is not living the law, he enjoys writing about it. Look for his first legal thriller novel to be published in 2016.

Our Address

Fillmore Spencer LLC

At Jamestown Square

3301 North University Avenue

Provo, Utah 84604

(801) 426-8200

Practice Areas

Look to Fillmore Spencer LLC for creative, cost-effective legal counsel and trial savvy

Fillmore Spencer LLC provides highly effective counsel and representation in business and commercial legal matters, while being mindful of the need to contain clients’ legal costs. Contact Randy at (801) 426-8200 to see how he can help your enterprise resolve its most pressing legal issues.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Bar Admissions

  • Utah, 1994
  • U.S. District Court, District of Utah, 1994
  • Colorado, 1995



  • Voted by his peers multiple times as one of Utah’s Legal Elite, Utah Business magazine



Professional Associations

  • Past President, Central Utah Bar Association


Community Involvement

  • Member, Board of Directors, United Angels Foundation
  • Member, Board of Directors, Kids Who Count

Fillmore Spencer LLC is located in Provo, Saint George, and South Jordan UT and serves clients in and around Eagle Mountain, Highland, Lindon, Orem, Provo, Pleasant Grove, Saratoga Springs, Springville, Elberta, American Fork, Wallsburg, Alpine, Mapleton, Midway, Lehi, Spanish Fork, Cedar Valley, Draper, Heber City, Payson, Salem, Goshen, Sandy, Santaquin, Riverton, Duchesne County, Juab County, Sanpete County, Summit County, Utah County, Uintah County and Wasatch County.